Collaborative Divorce Texas

  • Donate
  • For Professionals
    • Membership Advantages
    • Events/Training
    • Become a Member
    • For Students
    • Volunteer at CDT
    • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Home
  • Find a Collaborative Professional
  • What is a Collaborative Divorce?
    • What is Collaborative Divorce?
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • About CDTexas
    • Master and Credentialed Collaborative Divorce Professionals
    • The Gay G. Cox Award for Excellence in Collaborative Law
  • Blog
  • For Collaborative Professionals
    • Membership Benefits
    • Events/Training
    • Become a Member
    • For Students
    • Advertise With Us
    • Volunteer at CDT
    • Login
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
  • What is Collaborative Divorce?
    • What is Collaborative Divorce?
    • Why Use a CDTexas Member?
    • About Us
    • Master and Credentialed Collaborative Divorce Professionals
    • The Gay G. Cox Award for Excellence in Collaborative Law
  • Testimonials
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Find A Professional
    • How Do I Choose a Collaborative Professional?
    • Attorneys
    • Financial Professionals
    • Mental Health Professionals
    • See All

Donate

You are here: Home / Blog / History of Divorce: Part III

History of Divorce: Part III

August 15, 2018 By Harry Munsinger, J.D., Ph.D. Leave a Comment

Roman divorce customs were changed by Christian authorities when the Catholic Church became the official religion of Rome.  Christian leaders believed divorce was immoral and marriage should be indissoluble.  Catholic scholars believed celibacy was a superior spiritual state to marriage and that it was better to be married than commit the sin of fornication.  Early Christian doctrines had a strong influence on divorce laws throughout Europe.  In the 4th Century, St. Augustine and others proposed abolishing divorce, although it required centuries for the Church to do that.  Charlemagne introduced strict marriage and divorce laws throughout the Holy Roman Empire during the 9th century in return for Papal blessing of his Devine right to rule.  According to Catholic teachings, women and sex were the source of original sin.  Some early church authorities wrote that fornication was grounds for divorce, although they could not agree on exactly what it was.  Some Catholic scholars believed a husband had the right to divorce his wife for adultery, but that she had no right to the same remedy.

Christian Rome

Once Constantine converted to the Christian Church in the 4th Century, Roman Emperors began to borrow from church doctrine in forming their secular laws about marriage and divorce and the church gained more and more control over marriage and divorce.  Early Christian Emperors began restricting the rights of women to obtain a divorce and limiting the grounds for divorce to serious crimes.  For centuries after Rome adopted the Catholic religion, divorce by mutual consent was allowed, but with more limits.  Under Justinian Law, women could divorce their Roman husbands if he committed adultery in the same town where they lived, or if he committed murder, fraud, sacrilege, or treason, but a Roman woman had no right to divorce her husband if he was abusive.  If a husband abandoned a wife, she was required to wait ten years before she could divorce him.

Catholic authorities believed that celibacy was a superior spiritual state to marriage and from the fourth century on required a celibate priesthood.  They also believed celibacy and virginity were ideal states for all believers, sex was sinful, and the only acceptable avenue for sexuality was to produce children within marriage.  St. Augustine believed an innocent spouse who divorced his or her spouse for adultery should be allowed to remarry, because the adulterer should be considered civilly dead according to Biblical held that adulterers should be stoned to death.  Later church doctrine held that a Catholic marriage could not be dissolved.

Catholic Divorce

Early Catholic doctrine was flexible about penitential toward matrimonial offenses, especially adultery.  For example, if a married man had sex with a virgin, his penance was one year on bread and water and sexual abstinence for eighteen months.  Some penitential seemed similar to outright divorce.  For example, Clement noted that a legal marriage could be dissolved if the parties agreed not to remarry.  He prescribed excommunication for any man who divorced his wife and remarried.  There were differences in how Catholic doctrine was enforced between the Eastern and Western Roman Empires.  Citizens of Eastern Rome and the Germanic laws were allowed to divorce on grounds of adultery, mutual consent, or even unilaterally on occasion.

 The doctrine of indissolubility of marriage was finally established by the Council of Trent in the 1560s after generations of debate and uncertainty.  Part of the uncertainty about whether divorce was allowed derived from the different types of dissolutions available under canon law.  The three were complete dissolution of the marriage, annulment, and judicial separation.  Whether a divorced Catholic could remarry was subjected to varying restrictions over the centuries.  For example, many legal codes forbid the remarriage of a woman for nine months after her divorce to determine the paternity of any child she produced during that interval.  Another restriction passed in a few countries was a permanent bar to remarriage of a spouse guilty of adultery.

 Annulment

Annulment was a judicial declaration that the marriage never existed, so the parties were allowed to remarry within the church.  A prominent example of annulment was the dissolution of King Henry’s marriage to his first wife, Catherine of Aragon.  Henry was granted an annulment under an arcane interpretation of canon law because the church found matrimonial impediments to the validity of his marriage.  Consanguinity (genetic relationship) or affinity (marital relationship) were ways to gain annulment.  Another impediment was spiritual, such as when the person who married the couple had participated in his or her own baptism.  Finally, if the marriage had not been consummated, it could be annulled.  Girls could not legally marry before twelve years of age or boys before fourteen years of age, so marrying too early was grounds for annulment.  If a male was impotent, that was a bar to a valid marriage because it could not be consummated.  Consent was necessary for a valid marriage so insanity and the resulting inability to give informed consent was an impediment.

Judicial Separation

Judicial separation was based on a fault or offense by one spouse against the other.  Judicial separation did not dissolve or invalidate a Catholic marriage, but the separated individuals were not obligated to live together, as they were obligated to do under canon law.  Even though they lived in separate houses and maintained separate economic accounts, they were expected to be sexually faithful so long as either spouse lived.  Separated individuals could not remarry until their spouse died.  Voluntary unauthorized separations were considered a sin under canon law.  Another way to end a marriage within the Catholic Church was to take a vow of chastity, which effectively dissolved the marriage.  Strictures against divorce could be avoided by purchasing dispensations from the Church.  The sale of dispensations became a very lucrative practice among the clergy and a source of revenue for the church, which could not levy taxes directly.  In the struggle between secular rights and church dogma, the people had little or no voice.

Image Credit: https://thefreelancehistorywriter.com/2017/04/14/catherine-of-aragons-speech-at-blackfriars-june-1529/

Check out History of Divorce Part I – HERE

Check out History of Divorce Part II – HERE

About Harry Munsinger, J.D., Ph.D.

Harry Munsinger practices collaborative and estate law in San Antonio. He has over twenty years experience resolving disputes involving divorce, probate, wills, and trusts. Harry was an adjunct law professor at the University of Texas and St. Mary’s University. He has published several textbooks and over forty psychological and legal articles. Harry has been a forensic psychology expert, a licensed psychologist and a litigator.

Filed Under: Blog, Harry Munsinger, Our-Featured-Authors Tagged With: annulment, catholic divorce, christian divorce, divorce in rome, history of divorce, Judicial Separation, roman divorce

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Find a Professional

Getting started with the Collaborative Process?

First your need to connect with a trained Collaborative Professional.

[Find Out More....]

Articles by Category

Featured Video

  • Child of Divorce
  • Collaborative Divorce Testimonial

Why Collaborative?

  • Jennifer Leister
  • Steve Walker
  • Carla Calabrese
  • Dawn Budner
  • Becky Davenport
  • Jody Johnson
  • Honey Schef
  • James Urmin
  • Kurt Chacon
  • Natalie Gregg
  • Robert Matlock
  • Deborah Lyons
  • Carlos Salinas
  • Camille Scroggins
  • Linda Solomon
  • Richard Soat
  • Lisa Rothfus
  • Jeffrey Shore
  • Barbara Cole
  • David Brunson
  • Jennifer Tull
  • Syd Sh
  • Susan Z. Wright
  • Christi Trusler
  • Camille Milnser
  • Linda Threats
  • Sarah Keathley
  • MaryAnn Kildebeck
  • David Bouschor
  • LIsa Marquis
  • Harry Munsinger
  • Vicki James
  • Robin Watts
  • Katie Berry
  • Jack Emmott
  • Jennifer Broussard
  • Patricia Havard
  • Paula Locke Smyth
  • Laura Schlenker
  • Norma Trusch
  • Brett Christiansen
  • Tim Whitten
  • Mickey Gayler
  • Melinsa Eitzen
  • Julian Schwartz
  • MaryAnn Knolle
  • Chad Olsen
  • Chris Farish
  • Charles Quaid
  • Anne Shuttee
  • Barbara Runge
  • Rhonda Cleaves -
  • Jamie Patterson
  • Catherine Baron
  • Kristen Algert
  • Sandra Roland
  • Rhonda Cleaves 2
  • Gratia Schoemakers

Have you read?

15 Myths About Divorce

Common divorce myths say 50 percent of all marriages fail, second marriages are more successful, Mom gets custody of the kids, men initiate most divorces, living together lowers divorce rates, all … [Read More...]

More Articles from this Category

The Collaborative Law Institute of Texas

d/b/a
Collaborative Divorce Texas

Proud Members of IACP

1400 Preston Road
Suite 400
Plano, TX 75093
(972) 386-0158

Please note: Our office will be closed on

Holiday closures:
Limited: Nov. 23rd & 24th
Closed: Nov. 25th , 26th and 27th

December 24, 2021 returning January 3, 2022.
For urgent concerns, please Contact Us


Website Terms of Usage

Contact Our Webmaster

 

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • YouTube

Search Our Website

Find A Professional

  • Find a Collaborative Professional
  • Attorneys
  • Financial Professionals
  • Mental Health Professionals
  • See All
EnglishFrançaisDeutschItalianoPortuguêsEspañol

Copyright © 2022 · Collaborative Divorce Texas · All Rights Reserved

· · ·

Web Design and Maintenance by The Crouch Group