Collaborative Divorce Texas

  • Donate
  • For Professionals
    • Membership Advantages
    • Events/Training
    • Become a Member
    • For Students
    • Volunteer at CDT
    • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Home
  • Find a Collaborative Professional
  • What is a Collaborative Divorce?
    • What is Collaborative Divorce?
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • About CDTexas
    • Master and Credentialed Collaborative Divorce Professionals
    • The Gay G. Cox Award for Excellence in Collaborative Law
  • Blog
  • For Collaborative Professionals
    • Membership Benefits
    • Events/Training
    • Become a Member
    • For Students
    • Advertise With Us
    • Volunteer at CDT
    • Login
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
  • What is Collaborative Divorce?
    • What is Collaborative Divorce?
    • Why Use a CDTexas Member?
    • About Us
    • Master and Credentialed Collaborative Divorce Professionals
    • The Gay G. Cox Award for Excellence in Collaborative Law
  • Testimonials
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Find A Professional
    • How Do I Choose a Collaborative Professional?
    • Attorneys
    • Financial Professionals
    • Mental Health Professionals
    • See All

Donate

You are here: Home / Blog / A Comparison of Collaborative vs. Litigated Divorces (Part One)

A Comparison of Collaborative vs. Litigated Divorces (Part One)

August 19, 2015 By CDTx Staff - tcgi Leave a Comment

A version of this article, by Harry Munsinger, a partner in San Antonio family law firm Munsinger & Munsinger, and Michael Gallery, owner of OPIS Consultants in Highland Village, Texas, appeared in the latest edition of Roadmap, a newsletter for Collaborative Law Institute of Texas professionals. This is the first of two parts.

The International Academy of Collaborative Professionals found that most collaborative divorces resolve within eight months, well over ninety percent settle, around two percent of collaborative couples reconcile, and the remaining few opt for litigation. The average cost of a collaborative divorce is around $24,000, “easy” cases average around $12,000, while difficult cases cost approximately $32,000. Costs vary substantially by complexity of the case and cooperativeness of the clients, as well as how many team members are involved in a given case.

But, with all this information compiled on collaborative divorce, we know almost nothing about the relative costs of collaborative vs. litigation divorces. We don’t know if they take equally long to resolve, and we aren’t certain which clients are more suited to the collaborative process and which clients should choose litigation. Some seasoned collaborative practitioners believe clients with mental health problems, substance abuse issues, and unrealistic expectations are not good candidates for the collaborative process. However, we don’t know if these same clients would fare better in a courtroom or whether the stress of litigation might make their personal problems worse.

To answer these interesting questions, we compared the cost, difficulty, and time required to resolve a sample of collaborative cases with a demographically similar sample of litigation cases. Using standard survey methods, we collected demographic information on each client, the cost of each case, the time required to resolve the divorce, and ratings of how difficult the case was to handle. We recorded each client’s age, length of marriage, annual income, education, number of children, size of the community estate, the presence of mental health problems, whether the parties were realistic about the divorce, their level of trust, their ability to feel empathy, their level of anger, the amount of denial they showed, and the experience levels of the professionals involved.

We statistically compared the average cost, duration, and difficulty of collaborative divorces and litigated divorces to see if there are significant differences. Specifically, we wanted to know whether the average collaborative divorce costs less compared with the average litigated divorce, which type took longer to resolve, and which were more difficult to handle. In addition, we explored which personal characteristics of our clients contributed to the differences in cost, duration, and difficulty of collaborative vs. litigation divorces.

We found that the average litigated divorce in our sample cost $89,250, while the average collaborative divorce cost only $14,269. We also discovered that affluent clients, with average annual incomes around $100,000, are more likely to select the collaborative process for their divorce. Significantly, the likelihood that collaborative and litigated divorces cost the same on average is less than two in one hundred. If we replicated our study one hundred times, we would find two samples where the average cost of a collaborative divorce is equal to or higher than the average cost of a litigated divorce. In the other 98 samples, the average cost of a collaborative divorce is less than the average cost of a litigated divorce.

Moreover, the likelihood that affluent divorce clients chose the collaborative process by chance is less than two in 1,000. This means it would require 500 replications of our study to find a single sample in which affluent clients selected litigation more often than they chose the collaborative process.

Furthermore, we found no significant differences in the duration or rated difficulty of collaborative divorces, compared with litigation divorces in our sample.

In Part Two of this article, coming next week, Munsinger and Gallery talk more specifically about the involvement of financial and mental health professionals as well as differences between male and female clients. 

About CDTx Staff - tcgi

Filed Under: Blog, Client Perspective on Collaborative Divorce

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Find a Professional

Getting started with the Collaborative Process?

First your need to connect with a trained Collaborative Professional.

[Find Out More....]

Articles by Category

Featured Video

  • Child of Divorce
  • Collaborative Divorce Testimonial

Why Collaborative?

  • Jennifer Leister
  • Steve Walker
  • Carla Calabrese
  • Dawn Budner
  • Becky Davenport
  • Jody Johnson
  • Honey Schef
  • James Urmin
  • Kurt Chacon
  • Natalie Gregg
  • Robert Matlock
  • Deborah Lyons
  • Carlos Salinas
  • Camille Scroggins
  • Linda Solomon
  • Richard Soat
  • Lisa Rothfus
  • Jeffrey Shore
  • Barbara Cole
  • David Brunson
  • Jennifer Tull
  • Syd Sh
  • Susan Z. Wright
  • Christi Trusler
  • Camille Milnser
  • Linda Threats
  • Sarah Keathley
  • MaryAnn Kildebeck
  • David Bouschor
  • LIsa Marquis
  • Harry Munsinger
  • Vicki James
  • Robin Watts
  • Katie Berry
  • Jack Emmott
  • Jennifer Broussard
  • Patricia Havard
  • Paula Locke Smyth
  • Laura Schlenker
  • Norma Trusch
  • Brett Christiansen
  • Tim Whitten
  • Mickey Gayler
  • Melinsa Eitzen
  • Julian Schwartz
  • MaryAnn Knolle
  • Chad Olsen
  • Chris Farish
  • Charles Quaid
  • Anne Shuttee
  • Barbara Runge
  • Rhonda Cleaves -
  • Jamie Patterson
  • Catherine Baron
  • Kristen Algert
  • Sandra Roland
  • Rhonda Cleaves 2
  • Gratia Schoemakers

Have you read?

Is Collaborative Divorce Right for You?

If you are facing a divorce, or thinking about filing for divorce, you may have discovered that there are several different paths you can follow in a divorce. The traditional path is litigation and … [Read More...]

More Articles from this Category

The Collaborative Law Institute of Texas

d/b/a
Collaborative Divorce Texas

Proud Members of IACP

1400 Preston Road
Suite 400
Plano, TX 75093
(972) 386-0158

Please note: Our office will be closed on

Holiday closures:
Limited: Nov. 23rd & 24th
Closed: Nov. 25th , 26th and 27th

Christmas:
Closed from December 24-December 30, 2022.
Offices open on January 2nd, 2023.


Website Terms of Usage

Contact Our Webmaster

 

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • YouTube

Search Our Website

Find A Professional

  • Find a Collaborative Professional
  • Attorneys
  • Financial Professionals
  • Mental Health Professionals
  • See All
EnglishFrançaisDeutschItalianoPortuguêsEspañol

Copyright © 2023 · Collaborative Divorce Texas · All Rights Reserved

· · ·

Web Design and Maintenance by The Crouch Group